East Of Chicago Pizza – Shipshewana, IN

About East Of Chicago Pizza

East Of Chicago Pizza is a restaurant you'll find at 350 S Van Buren St # C in Shipshewana, Indiana. Our Shipshewana guide covers 5 food and drink spots, and this is one of them.

East Of Chicago Pizza is open 6 days a week, usually 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM (closed Monday).

East Of Chicago Pizza's menu features 52 dishes and drinks across 9 sections, including Specialty Pizza, Pizza, Beverages, Wings-Seven Great Tasting Sauces, and Oven Baked Subs. Listed prices range from $1.15 to $15.99, with a typical item around $10.95. You will find options like 7 Layer Veggie, Cheese Pizza, and Aquafina (20 Oz).

You can visit for delivery, onsite services, takeout, and dine-in. Visitors describe the atmosphere as casual, and it is a good fit for groups and tourists. It is especially popular for lunch, dinner, and solo dining. Offerings include all you can eat, comfort food, quick bite, salad bar, and small plates.

Accessibility features: wheelchair accessible entrance, wheelchair accessible parking lot, wheelchair accessible restroom, and wheelchair accessible seating. Payment methods accepted: credit cards and debit cards. Parking: free parking lot, free street parking, and parking. Reservations are accepted; call (260) 768-7272 to book a table.

Quick facts

Category

Restaurant

Address

350 S Van Buren St # C, Shipshewana, IN 46565

Phone

(260) 768-7272

Price range

$10 to $20 per person

Hours

Open 6 days a week, usually 11:00 AM – 8:00 PM (closed Monday)

Menu

52 items · $1.15–$15.99

Listing updated

May 2026 · Suggest an edit

• 7 Layer Veggie$13.49

  170-360 cal. Mushrooms, onions, green peppers, mild banana peppers, tomatoes, green olives & black olives.

• Cheese Pizza$9.50
• Aquafina (20 Oz)$2.75

  Pure water for a perfect taste. Add a refreshing water to your meal.

• Boneless Wings$11.99
• Pizza$7.50

  Any 2 pizza toppings, pizza sauce & signature cheese blend.

• Side Salad$5.99

  110 cal. Lettuce, tomatoes, green peppers, signature cheese blend & cheddar cheese

• Up To 4 Items$11.20

  640-1080 cal. Additional toppings for extra charge.

• Garlic Cheese Bread$4.99

  140 cal/pc.

• CinnaPOPs™$5.99

  120 cal/2 pieces. With icing.

• Chicken Bacon Ranch$13.49

  170-400 cal. Ranch dressing, grilled fajita chicken, bacon, and tomatoes. NOT RECOMENDED FOR CHICAGO STYLE…

Features & amenities

No visitor reviews yet. Been to East Of Chicago Pizza? Share your experience to help other diners.

More reviews on:Google